To Kill or Not to Kill AC Odyssey Choice and Consequences

Posted on 8 September 2026 | 21
News

Navigating the complex narrative paths in Assassin's Creed Odyssey often requires players to make heavy choices with far-reaching narrative consequences. In the Arkadia quest line, players encounter the quest To Kill or Not to Kill, which presents crucial decisions involving key allies and targets. Understanding the weight of these decisions ensures players can secure their preferred outcome for their character and allies.

Beginning the Quest in Arkadia

The mission begins when players arrive in Arkadia to coordinate with Myrrine and Brasidas regarding Lagos the Archon. Upon reaching the designated rendezvous point, players encounter a hostile mercenary who surrenders after combat. Choosing whether to spare or eliminate this mercenary does not alter the overall story arc significantly.

Navigating the Strategic Divide Between Allies

After dealing with the mercenary, players must consult with Myrrine and Brasidas to formulate a campaign strategy. Myrrine advocates for an aggressive tactic focused on burning silos and weakening the regional stronghold. Conversely, Brasidas urges caution and prefers a subtle approach to convince Lagos to abandon the Cult of Kosmos.

Long-Term Consequences of Past Decisions

The ability to resolve the Lagos situation peacefully depends heavily on actions taken in earlier chapters. Players who eliminated The Monger in private during Korinthia can reason with Lagos and convince him to surrender peacefully. However, a public execution of The Monger destroys Lagos' trust, forcing a fatal confrontation regardless of dialogue choices.

Impact on the Overarching Story

Sparing Lagos provides vital evidence against a corrupt Spartan king and strengthens bonds with key allies. This diplomatic resolution aligns closely with the best ending path, where maintaining family ties and political standing remains paramount. Players seeking details on other critical story branches can review To Kill or Not to Kill AC Odyssey Choice and Consequences to plan future playstyles.